The Power of the Media
January 3, 2018 § 6 Comments
Last week I posted this to Facebook, thinking it made a good point about corporate behaviour as opposed to individual behaviour. I immediately got lambasted by several friends who argued that it is we as individuals who make change and that corporations and the media respond to us. As far as I’m concerned this is hogwash and the height of American liberalism. No. We don’t control corporations. We don’t control the media. We are conditioned not to. We are conditioned to purchase new things, to listen to our media. And, sure, we can boycott. One friend lives in rural Tennessee and is doing her best to live a life of simplicity with minimal consumption. I salute that. I personally do not shop at Walmart due to its odious corporate behaviour vis-à-vis downtown cores around this country. But Lydia’s actions and mine are small, a drop in the ocean. And, yes, certainly, if we are joined in our attempts to make the world better in this sense, it would make a difference. But, until we are numerous enough to make Walmart stop gutting the downtowns of small-town America, for example, I think we need to both carry on keeping on keeping on, but also holding the nose of corporations to the stink they create.
Today, I looked briefly on Twitter and got depressed. Trump, Trump, and more Trump. Some of it was useful, like reporting on the actual news. But most of it was the usual outrage to his rants, raves, and rages on Twitter. Apparently today he thinks Huma Abedin and James Comey belong in jail. I don’t care. None of that matters. None of it. It’s just so much hot air. What matters is the policies and actions of the US government whilst he is president. That matters. But that’s not what the so-called resistance seems to be focusing on. It’s focused on the the newest outrage from the President’s Twitter account.
And so I got to thinking about how we arrived here. Donald Trump was an outsider when he threw his hat into the GOP race for the presidential nomination in 2016. He wasn’t an unknown, of course, he was a famous showman. He had no policies, just a slogan to Make America Great Again. He ranted and raved at his rallies, he made fun of his opponents, amongst others. In other words, he ran a circus. He tried to provoke. And the media responded exactly how he wanted, and therefore, so did we. The media is addicted to Donald Trump and his off-the-cuff remarks and outrageous statements.
Trump’s candidacy was pushed not by Trump, but by the media. His campaign for president was also driven by the media. He got wall-to-wall coverage. That most of it was negative, 77% according to a Harvard study, doesn’t matter. Trump was proof of Oscar Wilde’s observation that there is no such thing as bad publicity. He was all over the place. And, yes, we lapped it up. It become almost masochistic for a lot of my friends, having to see his latest outrageous comment or tweet. Trump as president has been driven by the media.
Right now, the home pages of CNN, New York Times, Huffington Post, and the Washington Post are dominated by the President. But not his policies, or his ideas to improve the economy or anything like that. No, it’s mostly noise caused by his tweets and off-the-cuff remarks, as well as that outrageous interview he did with The Times last week. None of this matters. But we just lap this up.
Certainly we, the people, have some power. We could stop paying attention to his tweets, but they get amplified by everyone on Twitter. His two tweets attacking the New York Times yesterday morning have both been re-tweeted close to 52,000 times and liked another 13,000 times each. He has 45.6 million followers. And, sure, not all of them are American, but they’re also not just conservatives. I can see that 272 of my Twitter followers follow him, and just looking quickly at the first 30 0r so, I can confirm that most of them are progressives. So, we’re clearly not doing that. But if we collectively stopped following, re-tweeting, or liking his tweets, he would fall silent pretty quickly.
But. There is the larger issue. The news media is all over him like a cheap suit. Because Trump is first and foremost a showman. I personally don’t believe he believes even 10% of what he says publicly, he says it to provoke people, to fire up his base, and anger his ‘haters,’ as he calls them. And thus, the media salivates.
And sure, the media is composed of individuals. And those individuals work for large corporations. And it is in the interests of those individuals to ensure large ratings/readership/viewership in order to further their own careers. And those corporations have an interest in those readers and viewers, as this is how profits are made.
Another example: Hockey in Canada. Canadians, we take our hockey seriously. And we have two English-language and two French-language media conglomerates exclusively devoted to sports. And hockey dominates at TSN, Sportsnet, TVA and RDS. And then there’s all the other media in Canada. Each has one or 100 ‘insiders’ who claim to know about the inner-workings of the NHL and our favourite hockey teams. And there is not just the TV stations (multiple streams), but also the social media presence of not just the networks, but their studio hosts, as well as these so-called insiders. And so viewership/readership and profits must be driven up at all times. And what drives all of this? Coverage of the NHL, in particular the seven Canadian NHL teams, but even then, especially the Toronto Maple Leafs and Montreal Canadiens, who not only play in the two largest cities in Canada, but both of those cities have large diasporas out west (where the rest of the Canadian NHL teams are in Vancouver, Calgary, Edmonton, and Winnipeg (and, yes, I am ignoring the Ottawa Senator), but also down east.
But coverage of practices, games, press conferences by coaches and general managers just aren’t enough. So there are trade rumours, as all of these ‘insiders’ go a-twitter discussing who is going to be traded and to whom. We are told that our favourite team’s general manager is ‘working the phones’ to improve the team or find that elusive piece that will deliver the Stanley Cup. My guess is about 99% of these rumours lead to absolutely nothing. The other 1%, well, even a stopped clock is right twice a day. But we lap it up. Because TSN, RDS, Sportsnet, and TVA have conditioned us to. It’s irrational human behaviour at its best because we have been trained by this media industrial complex to respond.
So, back to Trump: What if, for just one week, the news media ignored his Twitter? And what if we, the people, also ignored his Twitter for one week? What would happen?
Tagged: climate change, donald trump, facebook, media, social media, Twitter, walmart
What’s also interesting is how the amount of discussion about issues has fallen off, at least on the social media I see. It’s as if the antics have crowded out any actual political discussions. Of course, the inability of the GOP-controlled Congress to pass major legislation most of the time has a lot to do with that. But, as some media outlets note, there are a lot of less visible developments, from legislation to regulatory changes to judicial confirmations, that are changing the country, almost without notice by most of us.
I’ll trade you social media feeds. Mine are too political to the point where I’m avoiding FB. But, yeah, the media is getting ridiculous. The stories about this, that, and the other is getting ridiculous. But, if the issue is the inability to govern, that should be the story. Not all this static.
I suspect some of the quiet on mine had to do with personal circumstances of my “friends” as well. So yours may be more representative.
I’ve long eschewed Facebook and Twitter, but I can no longer read online news. Even long time esteemed publications have lost their central purpose and focus on what this moron is putting out with his thumbs. I’ve now subscribed to print publications that don’t need the click bait revenue. More news, less Trump.
I tend to agree with you in regards to personal versus corporate actions. There is a sense of powerlessness and that all we can do is vote (despite the fact that this system is being gamed by corporate money as well). Still, we must use the minuscule power we have, vote, not be wasteful, try not to give our money to companies guilty of human rights and environmental abuses. Even if it makes little difference in the big picture, it does make a difference to who we are as individuals – as long as we don’t delude ourselves into thinking we’re saving the world because we compost.
I am finding myself less and less interested in social media of late, for two reasons. One is Trump, the other is my hockey team, the Montreal Canadiens suck, and my Twitter feed is just that. FB is all Trump all the time. And I get the need to maintain and keep fighting, but…
I am having a discussion with an old friend on Twitter on the personal v. the political right now, and it will lead to another blog post. He says it’s BS, I say it’s not. We do need to try to fight back.
[…] week I wrote a post about the conundrum we face in dealing with President Trump, hockey rumours, and global warming. […]